“Mumbai is a cosmopolitan city,” Subhash Gupta of the commuter group Rail Parishad told The Times of India, defending the railway's decision to recognise different cultures. His response captured one side of a dispute over Bhojpuri devotional songs at Mumbai railway stations that has since drawn political parties, passenger associations and online communities into a wider debate about public space and regional identity. ¹
Ahead of Chhath Puja, songs associated with the festival were played over public-address systems at stations including Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus (CSMT) and Lokmanya Tilak Terminus, where special trains serve holiday travellers. Videos circulated on social media, and objections from the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS), Shiv Sena (UBT) and Marathi-language groups followed. By 13 November, reports said the music had been stopped at some stations, with Hindustan Times reporting a broader withdrawal by Central Railway. ² ³
This was not a Maharashtra-wide ban on Chhath Puja, its devotional music or its observance. The reported decision concerned music played over particular railway announcement systems. Public celebrations were separately being organised in Mumbai and its surrounding areas, including designated sites for devotees. Conflating those developments with a statewide prohibition would misstate the scope of the railway controversy. ³ ⁵
The Marathi Ekikaran Samiti argued that railway speakers should principally carry safety, travel and emergency information, and asked whether authorities had formally approved cultural broadcasts. MNS railway-wing representative Jitu Patil warned that his organisation would agitate unless the songs stopped. Shiv Sena (UBT) corporator Mandhuri Vishwasrao Manjrekar said she had received complaints from passengers and alleged that announcements at Wadala were compromised. ¹ ²
Central Railway chief public relations officer Swapnil Nila disputed the claim about disrupted announcements. He said the administration routinely uses theme-based jingles and public-awareness messages around festivals and special occasions, and maintained that Chhath songs were played only after essential passenger information had been broadcast. The competing statements have not been resolved by an independent assessment of the affected stations' announcement logs. ¹ ²
The disagreement soon became an argument about electoral politics. MNS president Raj Thackeray accused the BJP in a 13 November post on X of attempting to pit Marathi residents against North Indian communities ahead of the Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections. He claimed the MNS had stopped the broadcasts and appealed to supporters not to be drawn into a confrontation. The alleged electoral motive is his accusation, not an established explanation of railway policy. ⁴ ⁵
Leaders took contrasting positions. Shiv Sena (UBT)'s Aaditya Thackeray also accused the BJP of seeking migrant votes through the festival. Sanjay Nirupam, of the Eknath Shinde-led Shiv Sena, rejected Raj Thackeray's stance and defended Chhath celebrations, while Congress leader Husain Dalwai questioned the festival's place in Maharashtra. Their exchanges widened a dispute about railway announcements into one about who may claim visibility for regional traditions in Mumbai. ⁴ ⁵
Passengers were divided as well. Gupta argued that recognising different traditions need not become a political contest; Kurla commuter Balkrishna Raut urged railway authorities to put punctuality and amenities first. Activist Shailesh Raut criticised the administration for allowing an avoidable controversy to displace attention from passenger safety. Those are identifiable individuals' reactions, not a representative poll of railway users. ¹ ⁷
On Reddit's r/mumbai forum, a user called CrimsonXwastaken wrote that speakers should be reserved for train information and that passengers should be allowed to travel quietly. A commenter using the name BihariBabua, who identified as Bihari, also opposed religious music over public speakers. Other participants pushed back against remarks directed at Biharis, arguing that devotees had not themselves decided which music railway officials played. The discussion included derogatory comments about migrant communities alongside more narrowly framed complaints about noise and public-service priorities. ⁶
The online disagreement did not break neatly along a Marathi-versus-Bihari divide. Some users defended the right to celebrate Chhath without harassment while rejecting loud music at transport hubs; others asked why local Maharashtra festivals did not receive equivalent announcements. These posts indicate different lines of argument, but anonymous social-media comments cannot establish how Mumbai residents, Chhath devotees or Marathi-speaking voters as a whole feel about the decision. ⁶ ²
The question now is whether railway authorities will apply a clear and consistent standard to festival music in stations. The verifiable outcome is that Bhojpuri songs were withdrawn from at least some Mumbai stations after objections. The wider claims — that a religious festival had been banned, or that the broadcasts were deliberately arranged for an election — require evidence beyond the material publicly available so far. ³ ⁴
Reporting note: Reddit comments are public posts, not independently verified identities or a representative survey.
